March 18th, 2011
Why SAFA is Obsolete.
Just as a note — these are my own personal, internal opinions. They should not reflect upon my association, family, friends, employees, pets ect. Also note, because people keep dinging me on this — by SAFA I mean SAFA Executive.
The referendum has concluded, and I have to say, despite my squirming about getting enough people to vote at the last second, I was pretty confident about this whole process. Right now, I’m feeling pretty confident that I’ve made some good strategic moves, and that I’m ready to… pass the presidency on to someone else as quickly as possible.
Defederation is the golden word on campus these days, though mostly with regards to the SFUO, so our little success story is bound to be completely overlooked, but I think it’s a big deal, mostly because I’ve been nursing an ulcer over these votes. So, I’m going to post inflammatory things in my politely Canadian way now. Well, to be fair, I doubt I’ll say anything here that I haven’t said at a BOD meeting at some point or another.
SAFA (Student Federation of the Faculty of Arts) is broken, extremely broken, and to be honest I am hard pressed to think of a way to fix it, shy of taking the science route, eliminating member associations and just having representatives from each department. I think I’ve finally figured out why it’s broken too, or at least part of the problem.
For those unaware of the happenings in the faculty of Arts, the SAFA executive is the highest executive in Arts, acting as an administrator to the smaller departments. The executive is paid out an honouraria every month (they always call it that, let’s reduce it to layman’s terms — a sum of money equal to about $200) for doing what is formally called ‘Policy 5′ on the absolute bare minimum that a SAFA executive can do. These include things like going to executive meetings, and I suspect, breathing.
Most SAFA executive can run their policy five in under 3 minutes, usually glazing over the ‘I didn’t do’s which they say just as fast and in the exact same tone as the ‘did’s. They also like a healthy smoke screen of all the parties that they attended. We vote, SAFA gets honouraria. Cake.
And this is the biggest issue that keeps resurfacing. ‘Let’s just keep voting yes until someone motions to close’. I’ve done it before, and it’s not completely unreasonable when a simple BOD takes three hours. But it’s unhealthy to the various departments in Arts, since we tend to shoot ourselves in the foot with sheeple voting. This is how we ended up with a section in the constitution that takes 5% of the levy of a student association that doesn’t attend these insipid things. We voted this in, and it was a really stupid idea. SAFA claims its all fair because if they don’t attend they don’t get their honouraria.
This is such a false and bizarrely twisted analogy that it entertains me. You lose your personal money if you don’t come, but I lose 5% of the money that goes back into the students that I’m supposed to be providing events and services for? How is this a dichotomy? Maybe if you paid me to go to these… Perhaps if the BODs were useful to running my association attendance wouldn’t be a problem.
Any ways, this honouraria versus none has sort of turned SAFA into the task masters of the whole faculty of Arts instead of the administrators. When they want something they demand. Then doing passive aggressive things to eventually bend us to their will.
And maybe this would be okay if they then provided useful services to the MAs. But one association spent most of the early part of the year financially in the hole, and SAFA didn’t deem in necessary to lend them a cent to allow for events (and this is one of the large associations), but they were okay spending a few hundred dollars on executive bonding. Due to a mistake in apparel last year, (that was debatable the fault of a previous SAFA executive), another association paid all or almost all of their levy cheques this year directly to SAFA. So far, holding 101 week, and events, and dealing with the SFUO are the only services they can promise us right now.
A previous UPSA president whom I love and respect very much pointed out to me the following, knock down argument. ‘Much of SAFA has never sat on a MA before, they don’t really know what we do, and because of this they’re afraid that we do nothing.’ Which is the argument that has kept me from rage quitting so many times. But most people will tell you, shit gets ugly when the boss doesn’t know what you do. And then you get fired.
I love the idea of solidarity in the Arts department, but I think we’re doing it wrong. As I announced at my last BOD, Arts could function with a chair, and the member associations alone. Then I got laughed off the stage. But my heart was in the right place.